NIMBY No-Funners?
“I do not know any of the folks who support this proposal, but I’m confident they see it as positive, not just for them, but for the entire community. I hope they, like you, will understand why many of us do not see it that way. I also would imagine there are some unmet needs out here that we could work on together. This unfortunately, is not one of them,”
“Maybe the developers think they can do better than the Hogwaller ATV Park you have probably seen in videos. If so, I can assure you that most, if not all, of landowners opposed to this amendment don’t see this as a question of quality. It’s a question of compatibility. Nothing in this proposal is compatible with the farmland preservation designation, no matter how responsibly the developers would intend to proceed.”
Let Us Ride.
In order to get Double Gate ATV Park in Flemington approved at the County Commissioners Hearing on June 17th, the applicant must show that there is a need for the Land Use Change from Rural to Rural Activity Center. Because the property is in the Farmland Preservation Area, the bar is high. Let’s be clear – wants and needs are different things. I might want to put chemical storage tanks on my property adjacent to Lake Weir, but I would be hard pressed to show why they need to be in that location. In this same way, Double Gate may be able to present us with a long list of potential customers who want an ATV Racing and Riding Park in Flemington, but is there a compelling reason that it needs to be there?
It’s About Compatibility.
Like it or not, the proposed site for Double Gate ATV Park is in the Farmland Preservation Area. The County designated those boundaries in 2005 after extensive research to back up the importance of preserving that area for farmland for both environmental and economic reasons. It can not simply allow chunks to be taken out each time a developer expresses a business opportunity. Once it’s erased, it can’t be replaced. There are many ways to have fun and make a livelihood that are compatible with the Farmland Preservation Area. There are others that can be allowed if a sufficient need is shown and appropriate care is taken by the landowner. We have seen neither in this case, and so we strongly urge our County Commissioners to back up their promise to the people of Marion County and with us declare:
Always Watching
We work hard to keep you informed, and to represent our members' interests in preserving our horse farms, farmland and the unique character and culture of Marion County's 193,000 acre Farmland Preservation Area.
Join the herd. Every voice matters.
I agree totally with preserving the farmlands… a must for future generations!
I’ve been saying the same thing. Hard rock is just a short way down the road. You can also go out to the forest there’s a track out there. The need is not there. But most importantly not in the location that this new track is proposed.
Thank you for pointing that out! Please if at all possible, send a note to the County Commissioners saying the same thing. They need to hear from each individual member of the community. If you can show up at the hearing and speak there, please do both!
This is a great post and I hope it is delivered word for word to the commission.
Fantastic information. I look forward to attending the hearing.
Since members of the Double Gate ATV Facebook page keep saying we (people opposed to the rezoning) are misinformed, deceitful, exclusionary, and any other fallacious ad-hominem argument they can think of, here are a couple of peer-reviewed papers discussing the effects of long term exposure to noise, in animals.
https://guilfordjournals.com/doi/abs/10.1521/psyc.64.4.346.18600
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/000348945406300308
Take the time to read them and be informed with peer-reviewed, scientific facts. I have not heard one argument backed up by facts from anyone in support of Double Gate ATV. “Let our kids ride” is the best they have come up with.
Here is their Facebook page if you would like to see their posts, their opinions on HFF and everyone opposed, and what they think about the area.
https://m.facebook.com/pages/category/ATV-Recreation-Park/DoubleGateATV/posts/